⟵ Back to Articles

Introspection: Preparing For Canada's May 2 Federal Election

Saturday
,
30
April
2011
No items found.

Introspection: Preparing For Canada's May 2 Federal Election

Saturday
,
30
April
2011
No items found.
⟵ Back to articles

Introspection: Preparing For Canada's May 2 Federal Election

Saturday
,
30
April
2011
No items found.

Sikh-Canadians are now 2% of the Canadian population and shining. At least 15 candidates from all three major parties - Conservative, Liberal, and New Democratic Party (NDP) - of Sikh and/or Punjabi descent are on the ballots.

Sikh-Canadians are now 2% of the Canadian population and shining. At least 15 candidates from all three major parties - Conservative, Liberal, and New Democratic Party (NDP) - of Sikh and/or Punjabi descent are on the ballots.

Some are newcomers like Jagmeet Singh (NDP, Ontario) while others have already established themselves as bold critics, like Sukh Singh Dhaliwal (Liberal, British Columbia).

Will Pierre Trudeau's vision in Navdeep Singh Bains continue? Can Ujjal Dosanjh transcend the stupendous moderate-radical divide? Will there be more like Tim Singh Uppal for the Conservatives?

It is an exciting time to become engaged in Canadian politics. But this article does not aim to explore who Canadian Sikhs should vote for next Monday, on May 2, but rather how can Sikhs prepare to vote.

Sikhs and Punjabis throughout Canada held Vaisakhi celebrations earlier this month, attracting representatives from all political parties, including the Prime Minister and the Opposition leaders. About 150,000 people participated in the Vaisakhi festivities in Surrey, British Columbia, the largest such gathering in the Sikh diaspora.

Among Punjabi cultural festivities, Vaisakhi is a three-prong reminder of the Sikh raison-d'être: Work to establish an egalitarian society; challenge domination of any kind; and, acquire political power for the common good. Can any of these elements be realised next Monday?

If the answer is yes, than Sikhs and Punjabis must see developing "principle-centered" political thinking as part of their civic duty. This means joining in the difficult task of discerning what the unique contribution of government is to the promotion of justice and the public good - a task which does not come easily or automatically to us.

In preparation, we can draw on the rich legacy of Sikh political wisdom. Sikh historical precedents on the South Asian subcontinent instruct that establishing just rule is critical to a healthy society: "Guaranteeing economic and political sovereignties shall establish victory in life."

This is a direction to today's voters to ensure fair taxation and civil rights for all, while having zero tolerance for race or gender bias. Yes, Sikhs are one minority among others. Yet their goal should be to work for the common good of the nation as a whole, not solely their interests.

Preparing to vote means coming to grips with the role of political parties and the content of their policies. Is there a single Sikh view of party politics? To date, there is no one, conclusive answer to this question. While it is true that Sikh political convictions can negatively rule certain parties out, they can offer no positive guidance on a single party to support. In light of this then, the decision falls to individual Sikh voters, free to decide what mix of principles, policies or personalities they find compelling when marking their ballot.

While this does not result in a cohesive bloc of Sikh and Punjabi voters, perhaps we can rejoice instead that each individual has the opportunity to contribute to the greater whole through their vote, to seize their right to suffrage as an expression of strength and civic pride.

"O my beloved, do not make me subservient to anyone," rings the infinite wisdom of the Guru Granth Sahib, the Sikh scriptural canon.

An informed vote is a decisive rejection of subservience, in favour of wilful participation in the future's course.

Thirty-five million individual voters speaking separately cannot send one clear message to government. Citizens need parties to clarify a set of core convictions around which they can effectively mobilize and apply to areas of policy. Political parties work then to create coherent mandates which direct government's actions.

In attempting to lend the Sikh voice to the process, it would be helpful if Sikhs could solidify the relevant "Sikh political principles" which they want to see embodied in a party. Instead, our discussions occupy the realm of complex, contestable judgments.

But this does not mean the Sikh debate on voting is pointless nor does it indicate that the absence of unanimity leaves Sikhs with nothing substantive to contribute to the democratic process. No! It is precisely because the issues are complex that we need to engage in rigorous reasoning, by which we test each other's logic and built a stronger core of understanding through discussion. The tensions or frustrations of debate are not failures; they should instead be seen as vital components of education and growth.

The Guru Granth Sahib warns that, "When the constituency is ignorant, the leaders will be corrupt." The work of educating and engaging one another in the voting process should be seen as some of our most important work as Sikh Canadians.

Part of the education process is studying the parties as well as the people who have asked to take part in leading Canada. Like them or not, political parties are now indispensable to representative democracy, and Sikhs and Punjabis should be committed to them. Admittedly, the view that parties should be organizations of political conviction, and not just electoral machines or mouthpieces of special interests, is often mocked as "idealistic." But those who have chosen to be active in parties should face down that mockery and seek to elevate the character, behaviour and rhetoric of their parties wherever possible.

Others announce, piously or in exasperation, that they are "voting for the person, not the party!" But this is just simply not the case. When you vote, you are necessarily electing a party. Obviously the character, record, and commitments of individuals are relevant to how you vote. But these individuals come with parties attached, and it is the overarching policy commitments of these parties which should weigh far more heavily in determining how one votes. Those commitments are summed up in a party's manifesto. While a rough and incomplete guide to what the party actually does in office, the manifesto is an opportunity when the party's core convictions - or lack of them - are publicly aired, and it should be taken seriously.

Sikhs must, therefore, examine all of the party programs on offer when voting this Monday. Parties make commitments across a range of public policies, and Sikh voters need to assess a party's overall balance of policies and not simply focus on a single issue - be it allocation of aid, ethics, India, liberty, marriage, environment, human rights, or myriad others. Instead the challenge to all will be taking a wider view of the common good when marking the ballot.

In voting for a candidate based on a single stance, you vote for everything else that candidate and his party stands for whether you like it or not. Single-issue voting is simply not responsible voting.

The Canadian government cannot address faiths and ideologies directly - it can't make you honour nature as the One Force's gift - but it can act extensively to protect victims from others' irresponsible behaviour and to incentivise responsible action.

Vaisakhi can be very purposeful this year if Begampura - "the city without sorrow" - is envisioned, where religious, political and economic rights are interlinked, in Canada and beyond.

Revised:

This Content has been made available for educational purposes only. SikhRI does not make any representation concerning the completeness of the Content. This Content is not intended to substitute research or a deeper understanding of the topic. SikhRI encourages readers to read multiple authors to gain a complete understanding of the topic.

The Sikh Research Institute recognizes its responsibility to correct any factual, minor, or significant errors promptly. Please contact us via email to request a correction if you have identified one.

Suggest a correction →
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

Written By

Senior Fellow, Research & Policy

Harinder Singh is the Senior Fellow at the Sikh Research Institute. He holds a BS in Aerospace Engineering from Wichita State University, an MS in Engineering Management from the University of Kansas, and an MPhil from Punjab University in the linguistics of the Guru Granth Sahib. 

View profile ⟶

Share on Social Media

Latest Articles

Tuesday
,
27
February
2024

Paigham-i-Goya: An Expression of Love

A new translation and brief essay on the fifty-fifth ghazal from Bhai Nand Lal’s Divan-i-Goya.‍

A new translation and brief essay on the fifty-fifth ghazal from Bhai Nand Lal’s Divan-i-Goya.‍

READ More ⟶
Tuesday
,
13
February
2024

The Attack on Political Sikhi

What did Indira Gandhi hope to achieve in the June 1984 attack on the Harimandar Sahib Complex and Gurduaras around Panjab? What was the goal of the Indian National Congress (I) party’s brutal and genocidal pogroms against Sikhs across the country in...

What did Indira Gandhi hope to achieve in the June 1984 attack on the Harimandar Sahib Complex and Gurduaras around Panjab? What was the goal of the Indian National Congress (I) party’s brutal and genocidal pogroms against Sikhs across the country in...

READ More ⟶
Thursday
,
4
January
2024

Reduced to Ashes

Learn more about the authors behind the book.

Learn more about the authors behind the book.

READ More ⟶

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay informed with our weekly updates, important events and more at SikhRI.

Thank you! Your submission has been received.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.